The Ultimate List of Peanut Butter Protein Powders
It’s important to be aware of the nutrients that you are consuming on a regular basis. You want to make sure that you are getting in all the essential vitamins and minerals that your body requires. Not only that but protein is vital for building and repairing tissue, keeping bones strong, maintaining healthy skin, hair and nails. Actually every single cell in the body requires protein to function properly. It really is that important.
So how do you choose a protein powder? Honestly, there are so many on the market that it’s a trial and error to find one that you will really enjoy. However, if you are a peanut butter fan this article will make your life a lot easier. Below you will find 18 of the best peanut butter protein powders available. We get honest about ingredients, nutrition facts, and taste.
Orgain
Peanut Butter
Plant-based, Vegan
It needs to be mixed rather well but a blender makes it perfect. Sodium is a bit high at 380mg per serving but other than that this one is tasty. It’s organic and contains real ingredients minus all the chemicals. The main protein base is pea and brown rice. Anyone who opts for plant-based proteins knows that pea protein is one of the very best for nutrients while being easy to digest. The peanut butter really comes through as filling and satisfying. The biggest complaint with this one is that it can be a little hard to mix. If you have a bullet blender that’s probably the best way to mix it up. Plus, they get creamier when mixed like that. A serving has 160 calories, 5g fat, 380mg sodium, 16g carbs, 1g sugar, and 21g protein.
Amazing Grass
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Plant-based, Organic
The bonus is that this protein powder actually contains 7 types of greens and 2 servings of fruit and vegetables per scoop. Protein plus fruit and veg plus peanut butter?! It’s gets it’s peaunut butter flavor from actual peanut powder. Nothing fake or artifical here. Blend it with a little milk and half a banana for a richer tasting treat. The company offers several other protein powder flavors but most agree that this one is the best tasting. Each serving contains 190 calories, 7g fat, 340mg sodium, 11g carbs, 4g sugar, and 20g protein.
PEScience
Peanut Butter
Plant-Based, Vegan
The peanut butter taste is definately strong in this protein. It only contains 7 ingredientas with pea protein and brown rice the forst two. It’s great to have an option that isn’t packed with a crazy number of mystery ingredients. As far as plant-based protein powders go this on is way better than Vega. Each serving contains 110 calories, 400mg sodium, and 20g protein. The sodium might be a bit high for some so just keep that in mind.
Ambrosia Planta
Peanut Butter Cup
Plant-Based, Vegan
This is a flavor that has been perfected for your complete enjoyment. It’s a plant-based protein that mixes easily and tastes great. It’s one that even whey protein lovers could get on board with. Plus, adding plant-based proteins to your regular routine helps cut down on inflammation. One serving contains 110 calories, 2g fat, 3g carbs, 1g sugar, and 20g protein. They have several other flavors including banana maple, cinnamon roll, mint cocoa, and strawberry shortcake.
Syntrax
Peanut Butter Cookie
The label alone is giving me serious cravings! Firstly, the nutrition facts are optimal with only 150 calories, 6 carbs, 123mg sodium, 3g sugar, and 23g of protein per serving. It’s easy to incorporate this one into any type of diet. Thankfully there is no weird aftertaste with this powder. It mixes well and has a rich consistency that will keep you feeling full. Some even say it tastes like a Pillsbury peanut butter cookie!
Sascha Fitness
Peanut Butter
Whey
How does this protein powder taste so good with only 110 calories, no fat, and no sugar? Also did I mention that there are only 7 ingredients and it’s filled with amino acids? It has a creamy texture that you desire and is easy to mix with either water or milk. With 110 calories and 25g of protein per serving, it gets a thumbs up. The only complaint is that some taste testers say it’s a little too sweet for them but that depends on your personal preferences and how sensitive your palate is.
Magnum
Chocolate Peanut Butter Addiction
Whey
This packaging is giving off some serious candy bar vibes and making it hard to resist. However, with only 137 calories and 30g of protein per serving, Iyou don’t really need to resist anything. Blend it with some milk and a banana and you will think you are having a milkshake. The peanut flavor is not as strong as some of the other ones on the market. It’s great if you are more sensitive to flavors and prefer a more relaxed experience.
Body Nutrition
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Whey, Casein & Egg White
It blends smoothly and isn’t powdery or gritty like some protein powders can be. It even froaths up a little when mixed in a blender. The taste is rich and isn’t overpoweringly sweet. It even tastes good when mixed with water, most powders can;t say the same. The biggest complaint was that some taste testers didn’t feel like there was enough peanut butter flavor. Others thought the flavors came through perfectly. Guess it’ll depend how rich you like things to taste. One serving contains 125 calories, 1g sugar, 4g carbs, 11mg sodium, and 25g protein.
PEScience
Peanut Butter Cookie
Whey & Casein
This sweet-tasting protein powder is easy to mix and great tasting. However, tt won’t really get that thick even with the addition of casein in it. You’ll need to use it in a smoothie recipe if you want it to be denser. The biggest complaint is that it has an artificial aftertaste that kind of lingers. It comes in at 120 calrioes, 4g carbs, 3g sugar, and 23g or protein per serving. Sodium is 280mg per serving which is on the higher end so keep that in mind of you like to consume several per day.
BSN
Peanut Butter Cookie
Whey & Casein
Okay so the ingredients list is a little long but if you are looking for one of the most suprieme peanut butter protein powders you have found it! You will love the smooth, creamy taste that also mixes easily. As you might have guessed it is artificially flavored so there is a chance it might upset your stomach. Make sure you are okay with the sweeteners in this one. It contains 200 calories, 6g fat, 170mg sodium, 15g carbs, 2g sugar, and 22g protein.
NutRex Research
Peanut Butter Toffee
Whey
With a giant stack of cookies on the label you might be right in thinking this one is on the sweeter side. It’s a sweet tasting protein that is easy to mix. The hints of toffee give it an extra bonus as it feels more like dessert. If you have a blender try adding a frozen banana, milk, and a dash of vanilla extract to your shake. The nutrition facts are on point with 125 calories, 1.5g fat, 3g carbs, 240mg sodium, and 25g protein.
Ascent
Chocolate Peanut butter
Whey
You are going to love this powder because it doesn’t contain a huge list of artificial ingredients or words you can’t pronounce. Simple seems to do the trick and they scored on the mark. With only 140 calories, 95mg of sodium and 10mg of cholesterol, you will be happy with these nutrition facts. Oh, right you came for the protein, 25g per serving. It is rich and thick all on its own without the help of milk or banana. Some say it even tastes like Reese’s cups!
Ryse Up
Peanut Butter Cup
Whey
When it comes to adventurous protein powder flavors they can someetimes taste fake and leave you disappointed. Genuine taste that won’t make you feel like you ate a whole meal. Taste testers loved how light and energized they felt after drinking this one. It’s pretty easy to mix up and won’t leave you with clumps stuck to the bottom of your shaker bottle. It contains 140 calories, 2.5g fat, 35mg cholesterol, 5g carbs, 260mg sodium, and 25g protein.
NutraOne Nutrition
Peanut Butter Cup
Whey
This one feels like a sweet treat for sure. It will keep you feeling full and help curb any sweet tooth afflictions. When you start feeling that twitch for something sugary just mix up one of these skakes and you will forget all about that chocolate bar. It mixes well and easily enjoyed with water or milk. It’s made with real peanut flour and cocoa powder so you will never fell betrayed by Mr. Artificial. Here are the nutrition facts: 130 calories, 2g fat, 55mg cholesterol, 3g carbs, 1g sugar, and 25g protein.
R1
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Whey
It’s easy for chocolate peanut butter protein powders to have the chocolate outweigh the peanut butter. This is not the case for R1’s version of this dessert delight. The two worlds perfectly collide as the sweet chocolate taste is not outdone by the peanut butter in this powder. Also, it’s just as good mixed with water too. There are minimal ingredients but it does contain artificial sweeteners. Kind of normal for peanut butter flavored protein powders though. Each serving contains 140 calories, 2.5g fat, 65mg cholesterol, 75mg sodium, 4g carbs, 2g sugar, and 24g protein.
Dymatize
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Whey
Most users say this is the best protein powder that they have ever tried. Some compare the taste to Little Debbie Nutty Bars. It won’t upset your stomach or cause bloating like a lot of other ones. It does have a tendency to clump and especially so with cold water. So mix it well or better yet, use a blender. It contains 140 calories, 3g fat, 75mg cholesterol, 260mg sodium, 7g carbs, 5g sugar, and 21g protein.
Quest
Peanut Butter
Whey
You have probably seen their protein bars in stores or maybe tried one or two. Like their bars or not, this protein powder is rich, thick and keeps you feeling full and satisfied. The peanut butter flavor is almost perfect without being overly sweet. Using a blender to mix this one up with make you feel like you are having dessert. It’s intentially lower on the list because it’s a supreme favorite. If you made it this far then you are now in on the richness of Quest peanut butter protein powder. Each serving contains 110 calories, 1.5g fat, 210mg sodium, 2g carbs, and 24g protein.
Body Fortress
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Whey
This one is great tasting with water but richer when mixed with milk. It isn’t chalky and mixes rather easily. A tip to help prevent clumps is to add liquid to your shaker first and then the powder on top. The peanut butter taste is real and comes from peanut powder. The ingredients list isn’t taking up 1/4 of the label and we can all appreciate that. Each serving contains 200 calories, 3.5g fat, and 30g protein.
Gold Standard
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Whey
Everyone can appreciate a protein powder that has great texture. In walks Gold Standard. Not only does it have a rich flavor and texture but it also mixes smoothly without being chalky. Some people complain that it’s too heavily sweetened with stevia. So if you are sensitive to sweeteners or stevia this one might not be for you. One serving has 130 calories, 2g fat, 60mg cholesterol, 210mg sodium, 4g carbs, 2g sugar, 24g protein.
