Coffee seems to be heaven-sent for so many of us. Whether you use it to jumpstart your day in the morning, as an afternoon pickup, or as a way to curb your sweet tooth. A freshly brewed cup seems to check off all the boxes for the majority of us.

Coffee has some deep history and has been around for several centuries. This magic brown elixir has been brewed and drunk since the 1400s. It can be historically traced back to Suri monasteries in Yemen. Note that the coffee beans were imported from Ethiopia. The popularity of coffee quickly moved on to Cario, the rest of the Middle-East, south India, Turkey, and other parts of Africa. Interestingly enough coffee was banned by religious groups including the Catholic church during the 1500s. I wonder if they were afraid of morning energy and afternoon pick-me-ups.

Luckily for everyone, coffee is open for consumption and who would have imagined the flavors we concoct in this modern day. From cafes that seemingly have their own menu based language to single-serving K-cups, coffee has evolved. Since the love of coffee is almost as real as the love of peanut butter who great would it be for those two worlds to collide? Okay, so the idea has already been taken. As a token of respect and admiration, below you will find the top-rated peanut butter flavored coffees.

Door County

Peanut Butter Crunch

The peanut butter taste is subtle and works well with the coffee. If you choose the whole beans, grind your coffee more coursely and the peanut butter taste will be more prominent. It is a smooth brew and medium roasted. The company is a small family-owned business out of Wisconsin. They pride themselves on small-batch roasting to ensure high-quality and complete satisfaction. Their coffees come in whole bean, ground and K-cups. 

Smart Sips

Chocolate Peanut Butter

The smell is going to build you up with pure anticipation. It truly does smell like a peanut butter cup. Since coffee is wonderful to smell the taste is what we come for. It’s rich and creamy and tastes exactly as promised. Like a rich chocolate and peanut butter delight in a cup. The flavors play off each other and neith is more overpowering than the other. Smart Sips is a family run business and was even featured on Shark Tank. They offer several other flavors as well. 

Bones Coffee

Peanut Butter & Jelly

Let’s start off by saying that this coffee is not for amateurs. Even the caffeine immune will feel the jolt of this brew. The scent is exactly as the flavor prepares you for. As far as taste, grape jelly seems to take center stage with peanut butter hanging out in the background. Though to be fair, that’s kind of the same experience when eating a peanut butter and jelly sandwhich. The jelly usually hits your palate harder. Comparing this one to similar varieties on the market, it takes one of the top spots. 

Crazy Cups

Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich

Oh yes, peanut butter and jelly coffee. It’s a fun and interesting coffee to try out. The taste of jelly comes through more than the peanut butter but you can still appreciate both flavors. It’s delightful and maybe a bit too delicious. This one might need to be slightly sweetened to intensify the flavors for ultimate results. It’s a medium blend coffee and taking a hint from the name these are K-cups. They offer a huge variety of flavors and most are inspired by sugary desserts. How about bananas fosters, caramel truffle sundea, or cinnamon churro. 

Moose Munch

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter

This is a very nice quality coffee. It’s smooth and easy to drink. The milk chocolate and peanut butter are present but more on the subtle side. It’s like a ride of coffee, then chocolate and caramel followed by nutty peanut butter. It’s a very enjoyable experience especially when you add a dash of creamer. 

New York Gourmet

Peanut Butter Cup

This is a fine ground coffee carefully roasted in small batches. It’s a smooth cup that will never leave you with a bitter aftertaste. The beans are high-quality and the business customer-focused. The peanut butter taste is there and plays off the classic coffee flavors. It isn’t a bold taste but it’s there and enough for you to appreciate.

Market & Main

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

This one is a really nice combination of chocolate and peanut butter. The coffee and chocolate come through first and then they are followed by peanut butter. Be sure to follow instructions because if you add too much water you won’t get an accurate tasting. It is a quality coffee that comes in bags or K-cups.